Re: Dvorak: “I knew it all along”

Richard Bennett — Wed, 08 Jun 2005 19:41:39 -0000

Yes, I've seen these declarations from Apple, but time passes and things change. At the driver level OS X is just another NetBSD system, so there's lots of drivers for it already.

I just think it would be amusing to see them duke it out with MS.

Re: Dvorak: “I knew it all along”

Sigivald — Wed, 08 Jun 2005 19:12:57 -0000

A more interesting scenario to me is examining the possibility that Windows users can switch to the Mac OS on their Intel machines. Is this going to be possible?

Nope; IIRC Apple's said quite clearly that OSX will continue to run only on Apple Macintosh computers, regardless of CPU type.

But then, really, when has John Dvorak ever had any idea what the heck he was talking about?

Apple's real value might be their software (OSX is certainly a first-rate platform), but their computer-industry profit is all from the hardware. (I say computer-industry specifically to disinclude all the iPod profit, which is immense, but unrelated.)

Part of it is also, I think, that they can keep the whole thing much simpler and more coherent at the driver level by only having to support their own hardware at install-time, and whatever third-party things they choose; wheras on an open hardware platform they have to support a much more varied and dubious set of hardware that can have god-knows-what sorts of interactions. (But you know all that already, I'm sure).

The folks at Apple are certainly smarter and better aware of their market than Dvorak is, and I'm betting on them, not him.

Broadband Politics - Latest Comments in Dvorak: “I knew it all along”

Re: Dvorak: “I knew it all along”

Re: Dvorak: “I knew it all along”